Talk:Q's Winter Wonderland

Hi, @User:SFC regarding Q's creations being "Federation"-aligned - I merely documented here what the devs have marked them as in the game, as Daniels has might have said: this is what we "have" to write, not what we "want" to write in the wiki. Free to visit the Wonderland and double-check yourself, here is a screenshot of Q's infobox from the game itself that I've got (you will see the same Federation icon and the word "Federation" in the popup tooltip over all the other NPCs that I've marked that way). Would you not agree that in parts of the wiki where it documents the game content - it is the responsibility of the wiki to document as precisely as possible including any bugs, [sic]-type errors, and questionable design choices that we may personally not agree with? Trajos (talk) 09:25, 8 December 2019 (UTC)


 * I think it's more important that we make sure the wiki is clear and concise than 100% accurate to the source material, even if that means making small creative liberties like changing obvious typos or fixing errors... which can be easily documented elsewhere without also transferring those same mistakes to the wiki.
 * Q's clearly not part of the Federation and this is nothing more than a minor quirk in how the game handles its NPCs (or, more accurately, a reflection of how it did in 2012). It might be worth including in a trivia section, but I think listing him (and his monsters) as their own thing represents how it works a bit more. -RadioActivitii (talk)
 * @User:RadioActivitii, @User:SFC the next question then: if we are going with this page not being 100% accurate, then the next question is: what replacement faction should we assign to the currently factionless NPCs on this page, if we are not using the one supplied by the game? Some already have a faction, such as Q's Snow Monsters, Klingon, but a few have no faction, and instead are listed under either their location, such as Gazebo, or under their race (that does not always match the faction in many other cases), such as Breen and Wildlife. Trajos (talk) 16:50, 9 December 2019 (UTC)